Tuesday, June 24, 2008

The Shack

My roommates have been reading that new novel the Shack. It's intriguing, if only for the reason that it's highly controversial, at least, to some. It made the Times as a surprise best seller
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/24/books/24shack.html?_r=1&oref=slogin

It's fiction piece about a man who is dealing with grief and loss and is visited by "God" in the form of a black woman who calls herself Papa. The idea behind this is that God is neither male nor female, but as the author says, God is called Father in the Bible because in the fall of mankind the mother became the primary caregiver and nurturer. Also, the man in the book had a bad relationship with his own father, and so had a man come to him as God he would've been harder to accept.

Why is it heresy to think of God as also being female? Or rather, being neither male nor female but giving us representations of who he is in the form different of genders. It's definitely hard to grasp, at least for me. I've never been a hardcore feminist, and in this country my ideas of gender roles are probably very skewed. It's something to think about.

About half the families I've worked with so far have been single mothers. The families in which the father is present have all at various points in time been involved in domestic violence. (Just to be fair, in all of these cases the mother was also violent towards the father.) In most cases the mother is the dominant figure (not all). In an economic class where men are rarely present (either physically or mentally) the women have learned to take control and now this applies whether the man is there or not. Even if he's there now, there are no promises about tomorrow. I wonder what similarities there are, if there are any, between these women and the women in generations past who had to live without husbands and fathers due to wars. Was it hard for the wife to give the role of authority back to the husband?

Well, back to work I go. Peace.

1 comment:

Charles Lord said...

Hi Hannah,

Just a quick response from orthodox theology to your post question about God, and how we know or understand Him.

You wrote: Why is it heresy to think of God as also being female? Or rather, being neither male nor female but giving us representations of who he is in the form different of genders. It's definitely hard to grasp, at least for me. I've never been a hardcore feminist, and in this country my ideas of gender roles are probably very skewed. It's something to think about.

The reason it would be heresy to think of God as being female is the same reason it would be to think he is a man. God is Spirit. God is a triune unity. We cannot decide who God is, He is who He is. And God didn't reveal Himself to us in the form of different genders.

The Biblical record is what I believe. And because of that belief, I would not accept that God is to be represented as a woman, any more that I would that He is like George Burns in "O God" or Morgan Freeman in "Bruce Almighty".

God is who He is, it is not up to us to define Him or make Him meaningful. God is so good, and He has chosen to reveal Himself to us because He loves us and desires that we know Him, and fellowship with Him.

So that is my answer to your post, God is not female, but He is Father, Son and Holy Spirit. These are not man's representations of Him, but God's own nature and name and revelation to us. He is Holy, He is one of a kind, He is who He is. It is a wonder and glory to let His revelation capture our imaginations. He is glorious.

Paul wrote that God's people "take every thought captive, making it obedient to Christ", and that believers should avoid "vain imaginations and endless controversies."

The Jesus of the Bible, God the Father, and the Holy Spirit are all one. Jesus is controversial, but not to those who know Him and believe. he is the stumbling stone, the scandalon, and the rock of offense to the "religious, the philosopher, the scientist, and the skeptic, but to those who believe, He is the power and the wisdom and the glory of God. Cool.

God is very cool, even though that is not a Bible word.

Love you,

Dad